California Down But Not Out in Sonar Dispute – President Bush’s Actions Called “Shocking,” “Dangerous, Illegal, And Unjustified.”
January 23rd, 2008Calif Coastal Commission files against presidential sonar order
By JACOB ADELMAN Associated Press Writer
Article Launched: 01/22/2008 03:43:42 PM PST
http://www.mercurynews.com/news/ci_8046349?nclick_check=1
LOS ANGELES—The California Coastal Commission filed a court brief Tuesday against President Bush’s exemption of the Navy from environmental laws that would restrict use of high-power sonar off the coast.
Filed in Los Angeles federal court, it argues the president violated constitutional guarantees of separation of powers by overriding an earlier court decision limiting sonar use.
“This is an effort by the president to rule by decree instead of observing the rule of law,” said California Attorney General Jerry Brown, whose office represents the coastal commission. “It’s hard to find words to express the extent to which this deviates from the American tradition of separation of powers. It’s shocking.”
Cmdr. Jeff A. Davis, a Navy spokesman, declined to comment on the filing.
An after-hours message left with the U.S. Department of Justice’s press office was not immediately returned.
The Natural Resources Defense Council, which is fighting the sonar use, planned to file its own brief Tuesday alleging a breach of separation-of-powers doctrine and questioning the president’s reasoning that limits on testing qualified as an emergency requiring his intervention, said Joel Reynolds, a lawyer for the group.
“The president does not have authority under the laws of congress or the U.S Constitution to override an order of a federal court,” Reynolds said. “His position is dangerous, illegal and unjustified.”
Read the rest of this entry »